Cutlet and Vegetables

Cutlet and Vegetables
Raphaelle Peale

1774–1825
Cutlet and Vegetables, 1816
Oil on panel, 18 1/4 x 24 1/4 in.

Raphaelle Peale was taught to paint by his father, Charles Willson Peale (1741-1827), an accomplished soldier, scientist, artist, and founder of a dynasty of early American painters. By the age of twenty-one, Raphaelle was recognized as America’s first—and leading—still life painter.

Although flowers may be thought of as the most typical of still-life subjects, Peale was far more interested in delineating the colors and textures of food. The majority of his paintings depict fruits, and such paintings would typically have been hung as decorations in dining rooms. Cutlet and Vegetables is one of only two known paintings by Peale of meat and vegetables, and this unusually well preserved composition is the largest of Peale’s known still-life panels. An extra strip of wood was attached to the main panel, most likely to further the illusion of a real table edge.

Peale and his family apparently thought well of the picture, which hung at the Peale Museum in Philadelphia, founded by the artist’s father, from the year after it was painted until the mid-nineteenth century.

Provenance: 

Peale Museum, Philadelphia, by 1817 [1]
M. Thomas & Sons, Auctioneers, Philadelphia (Peale’s Museum Gallery of Oil Paintings, National Portrait and Historical Gallery Illustrative of American History), October 6, 1854, lot 257 (as Cutlet and Vegetables) [2]
Townsend Ward, Philadelphia, 1854
Private collections
Skinner, Inc., Boston, November 11, 1994, lot 69 (as Still Life—Beef and Cabbage)
Schwarz Galleries, Philadelphia, 1994
Acquired by the Putnam Foundation, 2000

Provenance Notes: 

[1] In what is said to be a manuscript page of additions to the Peale Museum catalogue in Charles Willson Peale’s hand, the work is titled “231. A loin of Veal” (Historical Catalogue of Paintings in the Philadelphia Museum [1813, with later handwritten additions; Historical Society of Philadelphia]). On March 4, 1817, in an advertisement for the Peale Museum in Philadelphia, Poulson’s American Daily Advertiser announced that “numerous valuable and interesting subjects” had been added to the display, including “A Still Life Piece, representing a fillet of Veal and Vegetables.—Painted by Mr. Raphael Peale.”

[2] The picture apparently stayed with the Peale Museum until the auction sale of the collection in 1854, when it was purchased by Townsend Ward, librarian of the Historical Society of Pennsylvania, for $20.00—the highest price given for any of Peale’s still lifes then on offer. In an annotated copy of the 1854 sales catalogue, it is called Loin of Veal (M. Thomas and Sons, Auctioneers, Peale’s Museum Gallery of Oil Paintings, National Portrait and Historical Gallery Illustrative of American History, October 6, 1854, lot 257 [copy in the Historical Society of Philadelphia]).